Great Eyeliner

"I love this eyeliner! The point is very narrow, so it can make a very thin, defined, and precise line. The color is beautiful and vivid. I prefer a deeper brown as opposed to a black since I find it less harsh-looking on."

— Emily L. (5/5)

Smudge-proof and pigmented

"I was on the hunt for a pencil eyeliner specifically to use on my waterline, which is a very tricky task as many pencil liners tend to smudge because of the constant friction and natural moisture of your eyes and oils from your eyelids. I got these liners in two colors--the black and the burgundy brown shades. They're both incredibly pigmented and rich, and have passed the wear test! I hope they come out with more shades soon, specifically a more neutral-cool toned dark brown shade."

— Christine (5/5)

Gorgeous color but

"Gorgeous color but I do not love the super fine point. THE ONLY thing it's good for is the tiny flick. Other than that, it doesn't tight line well and I don't even love the way it performs under my eye (where I always use eyeliner!)"

— Kerry J. (3/5)

"I love the refillable aspect of this eye liner - that really makes it unique. I just wish there was a brown or brown-black shade. Please add brown! I also really appreciate how it's made from good, clean ingredients and still works well."

— Joyce (5/5)

Exactly what I needed: precision and waterproof

"I bought this in Lovesick and Memories of Blue, and I like both colors. I needed something waterproof for NYC summers, and this product does not budge once applied. The precision tip makes it super quick and easy to do a baby wing liner. If you are looking for something emollient and easy to smudge, this is not it. But if you need something that stays put, she’s your girl. Nice that it is refillable."

— Lisa A. (5/5)

The best eyeliner!

"I'm glad that I discovered this eyeliner. I had been using Stila for the last 5 years and was relatively happy with it - until I discovered this waterproof eyeliner. The tip is very fine, which really helps to get a clean line. I'm going to purchase other colors."

— sophia s. (5/5)

Nights in Bordeaux for the win!

"Love this eyeliner! Just not feeling black these days, and brown has never been my thing. Had a burgundy color before that turned too red on me. Decided to give this one a try, and the nights in bordeaux plum color does look burgundy in the tube, but once on, it is not red. Beautiful color, a bit more subtle than black. Does not disappoint. Looks great with green eyes. Goes on beautifully. I'm hooked. Love."

— Alex M. (5/5)

Micro Tip is Wonderful

"What a great micro tip waterproof eyeliner. The precision is helpful and the color is stunning. Not sure what else I would need from it but it doesn't blur out for a softer line as well. It is great for that clear sharp liner."

— Teresea M. (4/5)

Love but need more

"Love everything about this except for how quickly it runs out! I used it almost daily and it was empty after about a month! Also this one as a gift for someone and it lasted them a few months longer."

— Echo (4/5)

Great for an Ultra-Thin Eyeliner

"Loving it so far. . . . but you should know it's an ultra-thin line eyeliner. Good for detailed precision, thin, natural makeup looks, and your inner waterline. Not the best for thicker, smudgier kohl styles. You will have to go back and forth to get the line thicker."

— Austin R. (4/5)