Great color

"The color is amazing. And it does make my eyes pop more than just cocoa brown, dark brown or black. It stays put! However the consistency is not as smooth. It skips a little. Short strokes"

— Selina w. (4/5)

Dry and doesn’t apply smoothly

"I would not recommend this product. It feels dry and is difficult for apply. It’s the worst eye liner I’ve ever purchased."

— Rachel M. (1/5)

Excellent

"This is the best eyeliner! Super smooth, super fine tip and great staying power. I swatched all of the colors and chose the plum shade. All are beautiful. I hope to see a few more colors soon."

— Slee (5/5)

Unusable

"If I don’t press hard, no pigment transfers. But pressing hard means it drags across the eyelid and scratches it. Also causes the eyeliner to break. I almost feel like I need to melt down the eyeliner a bit to get it soft enough to apply easily. The way it is right now is unusable, given I need to be able to apply it in under 1 minute, not 5. Have used many other eyeliner products in the past with no problems."

— Helen (1/5)

Perfect for a fall Smokey eye

"I love how thin this eyeliner is. Really easy to use and apply. It blends really easy but also stays in place for an all day bold look. Definitely waterproof but easy to take off with makeup remover."

— Gabriella F. (5/5)

Not your average brown

"This liner goes on easily and has staying power. I’m not super in love with the maroon-ish cast of the brown with my blue eyes and gold undertones."

— Melissa E. (4/5)

"It’s NOT Credo!!!! What did you send me?? There’s no address so I don’t even know where to send it back to!! This isn’t the brand, nor the color I ordered!!!"

— nancy (1/5)

New favorite eye pencil

"Was looking for a new plum eye pencil and this is great! No fall-out and easy to use. Love that it's refillable too."

— Caroline G. (5/5)

Waterproof eyeliner

"I like how thin it is, it did break, when I was applying it, but I still had more in there, not sure if that will keep happening ( hopefully not!!) I’m impressed with the thinness!!"

— Donna S. (5/5)

Waterproof Precision Eyeliner Soshe

"I purchased Soshe Waterproof Precision Eyeliner in Memories of Blue, and so far, it has not worked for me. I love the fact that it is a clean product and a supposed best seller; however, the product is way too firm and difficult to impart any color on the eyelid. I would like it if the product wasn't so rigid."

— Marilyn M. (2/5)