My new mascara

"I love and have used the Tower 28 one, but wanted something with a bit more oomph and lasting power for some events and this one is perfect! No flaking or transfer, easy to remove, and relatively easy to get both a lighter or bolder look. The mascara is a bit gloopy and the brush isn't my favorite, so I rub some of it off when I use it to have more control and that works great. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a good tubing mascara!"

— Caroline G. (5/5)

Top quality

"This is great tubing mascara - it applies well, stays put and really amps up my lashes while still looking pretty natural. It’s comparable to other high quality tubing mascaras. I find all tubing mascaras a little annoying to remove - most comes off easily but then there’s rogue little black bits. BUT that’s worth it to deal with considering there’s no smudging and transfer at all during the day . Regular mascara always transfers in my oily skin."

— Ailis C. (5/5)

Love this mascara!

"It glides on so easily! No caking or flaking, hardly any clumping at all. And it's comfortable to wear up to 3 days later! It also stayed on while swimming! Doesn't irritate my eyes like my old CoverGirl one did."

— Jennifer D. (5/5)

Performed well but frustrating to use

"I was a die hard waterproof mascara girl for years until I finally gave tubing mascara a try with this one. It sold me on the benefits and ease of tubing mascara - however this was shockingly thick until the very end of its life. I would scrape each side of the brush against the edge of the tube each time I opened it because, if I didn’t, it would apply heinously thick and give me the most spidery, stuck-together lashes. It definitely gave me amazing length that almost looked like I was wearing false lashes but I want to be able to swipe mascara on straight out of the tube. This one just doesn’t feel worth the effort."

— Morgan (2/5)

Love the consistency

"This is a fabulous product, however, it does wipe off on my face. Unlike other tubing mascara I’ve owned in the past. That’s why I gave it four instead of five stars. It goes on very smooth and lashes look beautiful. Sometimes you need a clean lash brush to separate lashes if you’re a little too heavy-handed."

— Hannah R. (4/5)

Wanted to love

"I really wanted to love this. I have yet to find a clean mascara that is everything. The formula is really clumpy and the brush is big and doesn’t do it any favors. I will say, once it’s on its on. My main complaint with clean mascara is by the end of the day I have racoon eyes from the product transfering to my oily skin. This mascara doesn’t smudge at all. In fact it takes a bit to remove it, which I think is a fair trade off. I will probably be buying it again until something new comes out though."

— Danielle C. (4/5)

Great product!

"Great mascara and so clean!"

— Angela W. (5/5)

One of the best mascaras

"Great tubing mascara. Noticeably lengthens with minimal flaking and almost no smudging all on one coat."

— Nora G. (5/5)

"Only waterproof mascara I’ve found that is clean. Great product!"

— Melodie (5/5)

Clumpy :(

"I was super excited to try this mascara after reading all of the positive reviews. . . Sadly it did not live up to my expectations. It goes on clumpy - I literally had clumps of it hanging from my lashes, and made my lashes stick together rather than separating them. If I fussed enough with a spoolie, I could get them to separate a little, but it left a mess all over my lids and under my eyes. One positive is that it does seem to have good staying powder."

— KateB (2/5)