Pretty darn good

"I really do love this. It's waterproof but to remove it you just take a shower and by the end of it the steam softens it to just slide off if you blink onto the side of your finger. It doesn't really make lashes look very natural or fanned out but I haven't had irritation so that's a win."

— Alyssa J. (4/5)

Goopy yet Impactful Mascara

"Totally goopy straight out of the tube (on the wand) however once you place onto your lashes AND after a few strokes at that, it's delightfully as the marketing images suggest. Long, separated lashes. Only con for me personally is that it does take a few minutes of hot water pulling at my lashes to fully take the tubing off."

— Chrissy C. (4/5)

No flaking or smudges

"Loving this mascara so far. I was searching for a mascara that doesn't flake off or smudge throughout the day, and this one fits the bill! Thanks to the recommendation of a Credo associate. The container is quite large so I wouldn’t travel with it but at home it’s great."

— Austin R. (5/5)

Not for me

"I wanted to like this mascara as I've been trying to find a good tubing mascara (the OG Blinc was so good but I can't find it in stores now). The formula is too wet for me, and it really didn't do much to enhance my lashes. Washed off easy of course, I ended up returning it."

— Mandisa R. (1/5)

just ok

"Im not sure I'll repurchase this. I love that it's refillable and the waterproof is so good, it does not migrate onto my under eye or upper lid like most other mascaras. But I just wish it wasn't so heavy and clumpy, I have to remove a lot of the product from the brush and I still often end up with a spider leg look."

— jamie m. (3/5)

Not what I expected.

"I like this brand so much but unfortunately I wouldn’t say this is waterproof, maybe water resistant. Ere Perez carries one that is really waterproof but dries out pretty quickly and that was the only reason I wanted to give it a try."

— Maribel J. (2/5)

my new absolute fave

"dont have enough good things to say about this. love the way it coats my lashes. love how it washes off without leaving the raccoon eyes. love how I can play tennis for 3 hours and it still doesn't budge. 10 out of 10!"

— Jody F. (5/5)

"I love tubing mascara and once I tried it, I never went back. Generally I use Thrive but seeing a cleaner option, I was all excited to try it. Thrive is still my favorite because the brush on this one gets messy and is harder to apply precisely."

— Eve (4/5)

Gentle tubing mascara

"So far so good! I have super sensitive eyes and eyelids and needed a tubing mascara to reduce friction when removing. So far this mascara has not caused any irritation, wears well and looks nice and is easy to remove."

— michelle c. (5/5)

Repeat Buyer

"I’ve been using tubing mascara for 20+ years and this my 4th tube of Shoshe. Goes on smoothly, lasts all day and makes my eyes pop. I love that I can just purchase a refill, so there’s less packaging waste."

— Jill R. (5/5)