Top quality

"This is great tubing mascara - it applies well, stays put and really amps up my lashes while still looking pretty natural. It’s comparable to other high quality tubing mascaras. I find all tubing mascaras a little annoying to remove - most comes off easily but then there’s rogue little black bits. BUT that’s worth it to deal with considering there’s no smudging and transfer at all during the day . Regular mascara always transfers in my oily skin."

— Ailis C. (5/5)

Love this mascara!

"It glides on so easily! No caking or flaking, hardly any clumping at all. And it's comfortable to wear up to 3 days later! It also stayed on while swimming! Doesn't irritate my eyes like my old CoverGirl one did."

— Jennifer D. (5/5)

Love the consistency

"This is a fabulous product, however, it does wipe off on my face. Unlike other tubing mascara I’ve owned in the past. That’s why I gave it four instead of five stars. It goes on very smooth and lashes look beautiful. Sometimes you need a clean lash brush to separate lashes if you’re a little too heavy-handed."

— Hannah R. (4/5)

Wanted to love

"I really wanted to love this. I have yet to find a clean mascara that is everything. The formula is really clumpy and the brush is big and doesn’t do it any favors. I will say, once it’s on its on. My main complaint with clean mascara is by the end of the day I have racoon eyes from the product transfering to my oily skin. This mascara doesn’t smudge at all. In fact it takes a bit to remove it, which I think is a fair trade off. I will probably be buying it again until something new comes out though."

— Danielle C. (4/5)

One of the best mascaras

"Great tubing mascara. Noticeably lengthens with minimal flaking and almost no smudging all on one coat."

— Nora G. (5/5)

"Only waterproof mascara I’ve found that is clean. Great product!"

— Melodie (5/5)

Clumpy :(

"I was super excited to try this mascara after reading all of the positive reviews. . . Sadly it did not live up to my expectations. It goes on clumpy - I literally had clumps of it hanging from my lashes, and made my lashes stick together rather than separating them. If I fussed enough with a spoolie, I could get them to separate a little, but it left a mess all over my lids and under my eyes. One positive is that it does seem to have good staying powder."

— KateB (2/5)

Waterproof Tubing Mascara

"I wanted to love this. It’s a bit harder to apply than other tubing mascaras. I think it’s the brush - it’s a bit sloppy upon application and requires clean up but then it does stay put. So if you can get through the messy application, then it’s good, but it’s kind of a non starter for me."

— Timberley W. (3/5)

Good product

"I like this tubing mascara! However, I don’t necessarily like the packaging or the brush. I think it gets lots of products. I still use it with a different spoolie to spread the product better"

— Alia K. (5/5)

Pretty darn good

"I really do love this. It's waterproof but to remove it you just take a shower and by the end of it the steam softens it to just slide off if you blink onto the side of your finger. It doesn't really make lashes look very natural or fanned out but I haven't had irritation so that's a win."

— Alyssa J. (4/5)